.png){kind=logo}
Superhero franchises thrive on sequels, shared universes, and long-term planning – but not every standout entry gets the follow-up it deserves. Some films arrive too early, others too late, and a few are simply misunderstood in their time. Despite strong ideas, memorable Marvel characters, or passionate DC fanbases, these superhero movies were left as one-and-done experiences.
In many cases, studio hesitation, box office underperformance, or shifting creative priorities cut potential franchises short. That doesn’t diminish their value. In fact, being standalone often gives these films a unique identity, free from sequel escalation or continuity baggage. Whether ambitious MCU timeline misfires, cult classics, or bold experiments that didn’t fit the moment, these superhero movies deserved a sequel.
Eternals (2021)
Eternals is one of Marvel Studios’ most divisive films, but its lack of a sequel feels more like unfinished business than closure. Directed by Chloé Zhao, the movie attempted something rare for the MCU: a contemplative, mythic superhero epic spanning thousands of years. Rather than focusing on quips and momentum, Eternals prioritized scale, legacy, and moral ambiguity.
Related
9 Movies That Tried To Be The Next The Avengers
After The Avengers changed blockbuster storytelling, these movies tried to copy its team-up formula, with mixed and often disastrous results.
Its ensemble cast and globe-spanning story were clearly designed with long-term storytelling in mind. Eternals set up cosmic consequences, unresolved narrative arcs, and even new characters. However, mixed reception and shifting MCU priorities stalled any immediate continuation.
That’s unfortunate, as Eternals works best when viewed as a foundation rather than a conclusion. Its Celestial mythology, internal conflicts, and bold visual identity set it apart from typical Marvel franchise fare. A sequel could have refined its ideas and paid off its ambitious setup, instead of leaving the film as a fascinating but incomplete chapter.
Daredevil (2003)
2003’s Daredevil exists in a strange space today. It’s overshadowed by modern superhero storytelling yet undeniably influential for its time. Starring Ben Affleck, the film leaned heavily into stylized action, heightened comic-book visuals, and a darker tone that felt thrilling in the early 2000s.
While it received mixed reviews, Daredevil performed well enough to suggest sequel potential. Instead, Fox pivoted to the Elektra spin-off, mistakenly assuming there wasn’t enough audience interest in a direct continuation. In hindsight, that decision feels especially ironic given Daredevil’s later success on Netflix.
Though dated by today’s standards, Daredevil was gritty, operatic, and far more daring than many contemporaries. It laid groundwork for street-level superhero storytelling before it was fashionable. A sequel could have refined its flaws and expanded its world, but instead the character’s cinematic evolution was put on hold for years.
Mystery Men (1999)
Mystery Men arrived before audiences were ready to embrace superhero satire. The film mocked comic-book tropes years before the genre fully dominated Hollywood. Its ensemble of deeply flawed, low-rent heroes was a sharp contrast to the polished icons audiences expected at the time.
Commercially, it underperformed, effectively killing any chance of a sequel. Yet today, Mystery Men feels ahead of its time, anticipating the meta-humor that would later define films like Deadpool and The Boys. Its bizarre powers, offbeat villains, and a skewed take on hero worship could easily be continued.
The lack of a sequel denied the film a chance to grow into its own cult universe. Today, Mystery Men is often reevaluated as a misunderstood gem. It’s one that could have thrived if released in a more superhero-saturated era.
Zack Snyder’s Justice League (2021)
Despite its four-hour runtime, Zack Snyder’s Justice League was never meant to be the end of its story. The film restores a sweeping, operatic vision that sets up multiple sequels, including the Knightmare future and Darkseid’s full-scale invasion. Released as a corrective to the theatrical cut, it was never positioned as a true franchise launch, despite strong fan support.
Warner Bros.’ shifting strategy and desire to move away from Snyder’s darker tone effectively shut the door on continuation. That decision left the film feeling like a prologue without a follow-up. As a standalone experience, it’s ambitious, character-driven, and visually distinct.
As the foundation of an unrealized saga, it’s deeply frustrating. Few superhero movies feel so clearly designed for continuation while being denied one. Zack Snyder’s Justice League remains part redemption, part frustrating tease of what could have been.
Spawn (1997)
Spawn is a product of late-’90s ambition colliding with technological limitations. As one of the first attempts to bring a darker, more adult comic-book property to the big screen, it aimed to break away from traditional superhero aesthetics. While the film struggled with uneven effects and tonal inconsistency, its core ideas were strong enough to justify continuation.
Spawn’s mythology, antihero status, and hellish imagery could have allowed for a much greater exploration. Despite plans for sequels and reboots, the whole cinematic franchise stalled. In hindsight, Spawn feels like it arrived before studios knew how to properly handle R-rated superhero material.
Modern audiences, accustomed to darker comic adaptations, might be far more receptive today. A Spawn sequel could refine the concept and lead into horror elements the original only hinted at. Instead, Spawn remains a tantalizing peak at what early adult-oriented superhero cinema could have become.
The Phantom (1996)
The Phantom is one of the earliest big-screen superhero adaptations to hint at the genre’s future potential, yet it was left completely standalone. Released in 1996, the film leaned heavily into pulp adventure roots rather than modern superhero conventions. Its hero was a mythic figure passed down through generations.
Billy Zane’s Phantom was earnest, physical, and refreshingly sincere at a time when comic-book movies often felt campy or embarrassed by their source material. While the film underperformed at the box office, it established a rich world filled with lore, secret societies, and serialized storytelling clearly designed for continuation. Instead, its failure halted any franchise plans.
In retrospect, The Phantom feels like a transitional piece. It’s caught between old-school adventure cinema and the superhero boom that followed years later. A sequel could have broadened its mythology and refined its tone, but the character was ultimately left behind by the genre he helped inspire.
Chronicle (2012)
Chronicle stands as one of the most inventive superhero origin stories ever put to film. Shot in a found-footage style, the movie reframed superpowers as something frightening and corrupting rather than empowering. Its grounded approach, emotional rawness, and tragic trajectory set it apart from traditional superhero narratives.
Chronicle’s exploration of power as a reflection of trauma felt ripe for further exploration in a larger world. Its open-ended conclusion left a certain amount up for debate that a sequel could explore. Even a standalone sequel based on other characters in the same world would make a compelling follow-up.
Indeed, the movie was a critical and commercial success and immediately stoked appetite for a Chronicle sequel. Numerous follow-ups have subsequently been developed by Fox with little luck. In 2021, a female-led sequel was announced, but there have been little developments since.
The Shadow (1994)
The Shadow is a visually striking, tonally ambitious superhero film that arrived decades before audiences were primed for darker pulp adaptations. The movie embraced noir aesthetics, psychological villainy, and supernatural elements, creating a unique identity separate from traditional comic-book fare. Alec Baldwin’s performance leaned into mystery and menace rather than charm, making the character feel dangerous and unpredictable.
The Shadow’s world-building was extensive, clearly establishing villains, lore, and serialized potential. Unfortunately, its box office disappointment ended sequel plans almost immediately. Like The Phantom, The Shadow suffered from arriving too early, before studios understood how to market unconventional superhero stories.
Its moody atmosphere and stylized violence feel far more aligned with modern tastes. A sequel could deepen its mythology and refine its pacing. Instead, The Shadow stands alone as an intriguing glimpse at a superhero direction Hollywood wasn’t ready to commit to.
Big Hero 6 (2014)
Custom Image by Sam MacLennanBig Hero 6 was a charming, critically acclaimed deviation from the typical superhero fare. The animated Marvel adaptation blended comic book spectacle with heartfelt emotion, focusing on grief, healing, and friendship. Baymax quickly became an iconic character, and the film’s futuristic San Fransokyo setting was rich with sequel potential.
Instead of a theatrical follow-up, Disney chose to expand the property through television series and shorts. This effectively sidelined the idea of a proper movie sequel. While those continuations explored the world further, they lacked the scale and emotional impact of a full cinematic release.
Big Hero 6 felt like the beginning of a franchise rather than a one-off. Its blend of action, humor, and emotional storytelling could have easily supported a sequel that matured alongside its audience. This makes its absence particularly noticeable.
The Incredible Hulk (2008)
The Incredible Hulk occupies a unique and frustrating position within the MCU. It helped launch the burgeoning franchise and established Hulk as a central MCU player – despite the recast. Sadly, rights issues with Universal prevented Marvel Studios from producing a direct sequel, effectively stalling Hulk’s standalone cinematic future.
As a result, Hulk gradually evolved into a supporting character in other heroes’ movies rather than leading his own. This limitation forced Hulk’s arc to unfold in fragments, spread across ensemble films instead of focused narratives. While Mark Ruffalo’s version became beloved, the character was repeatedly sidelined, denied the deeper exploration afforded to other Avengers.
The lack of sequels wasn’t due to lack of interest, but legal complications, making Hulk’s situation especially frustrating. While Captain America: Brave New World concluded several leftover narrative arcs, Hulk’s absence was too big to surmount. Few major superheroes have been so prominent yet so restricted, leaving The Incredible Hulk to languish while Hulk moves on.
-
-
-
Mystery Men
Release Date August 6, 1999
Runtime 121 Minutes
-
Spawn
Release Date August 1, 1997
Runtime 98 Mins
Director Mark A.Z. Dippé
Writers Mark A.Z. Dippé, Alan B. McElroy
Cast
-
-
-
Chronicle
8/10
Release Date February 3, 2012
Runtime 84 minutes
-
Dane DeHaan
Andrew Detmer
-
Alex Russell
Matt Garetty
-
-
The Shadow
Release Date July 1, 1994
Runtime 108 Minutes
-
English (US) ·