Peacock's Record-Breaking Thriller All Her Fault: A 10/10 Masterpiece

Peacock's All Her Fault proved to be a massive success for the streaming platform when it released at the end of 2025. With All Her Fault's stellar cast led by TV greats Sarah Snook (Succession) and Jake Lacy (The White Lotus), the thriller series was already set up to be excellent based on these actors alone, and it definitely delivered.

A crowded genre in the streaming landscape, it's easy for a thriller show to be quickly forgotten, especially when there's stiff competition, like Netflix's The Beast in Me, which premiered just one week after All Her Fault. However, the Peacock show was not only a rousing success, but it also broke a record for the streamer.

What Is All Her Fault About?

Unfolding over the course of eight taut episodes, All Her Fault centers on Marissa Irvine (Sarah Snook), a wealthy mother whose life is thrown into chaos and tumult when she goes to pick up her young son, Milo, from a playdate, only to find that the homeowner of the address she was given has never heard of him.

What follows is a panic-stricken, frantic search for Milo and his kidnappers. At Sarah's side are her husband Peter (Jake Lacy), whose white knight tendencies seem too good to be true, her business partner with a shady past, Colin Dobbs (Jay Ellis), and Peter's adult siblings, Lia (Abby Elliott) and Brian (Daniel Monks), who are both financially dependent on her older brother.

As the investigation, led by Detective Alcaras (an excellent Michael Peña), progresses, and more of All Her Fault's shocking twists are revealed, Marissa deepens her new friendship with fellow mother Jenny Kaminski (Dakota Fanning), whose nanny is tied to Milo's disappearance.

Like with the best thriller shows, nothing is as it seems in the Peacock series, from who All Her Fault's real villain is to who's in the most danger. However, while All Her Fault hits familiar thriller beats and tropes, it also stands out from the crowd, resulting in record-breaking viewership numbers for Peacock.

All Her Fault Is The Most-Watched Peacock Original Show Ever

Though Peacock is home to many excellent original series, the platform hasn't made as big a splash in the streaming landscape as many of its competitors, such as Netflix, Prime Video, and HBO Max. As a result, many of its shows fall through the cracks for many audiences, but this was definitely not the case for All Her Fault.

In fact, All Her Fault proved to be Peacock's biggest original series launch ever, accruing 46 million hours during its first three weeks on the platform. Furthermore, Nielsen data reveals that All Her Fault held on to a spot in the top 5 streaming original series throughout that same time frame.

Though it has been argued that a thriller like All Her Fault would have benefited from weekly episode releases as opposed to the binge model that Peacock opted for, there's no arguing with these results. Between the bingeability of the series and its incredibly high quality, All Her Fault is an undeniable winner for Peacock.

Why All Her Fault Is A 10/10 Thriller Masterpiece

Though some prefer a slow-burn thriller, All Her Fault immediately throws the audience into the action, with the very first scene showing Marissa arriving at a doorstep only to be informed by a very nice woman that her son is most definitely not at this address. From there, every new revelation takes the viewer further away from what they thought they knew about these characters.

Any thriller worth its salt will have twists, but the genius of this series is that its twists don't adhere to traditions of the thriller genre. What we learn about Milo's whereabouts and kidnappers is revealed in ways unlike any other show, with his disappearance not even necessarily being the biggest shock, as we see with All Her Fault's jaw-dropping ending.

All Her Fault isn't just about a missing young boy; it wears its theme of the unrealistic and downright cruel expectations society places on mothers, especially when compared to fathers. This searing commentary likely resonated with the series' massive viewership, 64% of which were females aged 35-64.

Despite its success, due to the way the story wrapped up, it's highly unlikely that All Her Fault will have a season 2. But never say never. It's hardly uncommon for shows originally conceived as limited series to be greenlit for additional seasons due to popularity, with Big Little Lies and The White Lotus being prime examples. Whether or not it happens for All Her Fault, one thing is clear — Peacock already has a built-in audience.