Martin Short Almost Ruined Selena Gomez's Wedding Cake

2 hours ago 1

What Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco Were Up to After Golden Globes 2026

Apparently Martin Short didn’t think this was the only cake in the building during Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco’s wedding.

The Only Murders in the Building star detailed attending his costar’s “perfect” wedding in September. Although, he admitted he caused a slight mishap later in the evening as he sat with Steve Martin, Paul Rudd, and show co-creator Dan Fogelman.

“There were big, big tents and at the back of the tents were these individual seating areas with couches and chairs,” the 75-year-old comedian explained on Jimmy Kimmel Live! Jan. 21. “And there was a cake, a wedding cake, by our section. But it was a small wedding cake.”

“I just assumed there was a wedding cake for each section in the back,” he admitted. “After a few hours, they haven’t cut their wedding cake yet… Steve said he was gonna leave.”

Joking that “maybe” he might’ve “had a cocktail” prior, Martin revealed, “I had a fork in my hand, and I said, ‘Steve you can’t leave yet without a piece of wedding cake!’”

He recalled cutting into the cake with the fork, causing an uproar from his Only Murders crew, noting, “All the people in our group screamed, ‘Marty!’” 

As a photo of the white heart-shaped cake with fork marks in it appeared on the screen, Martin admitted to the audience he made a slight dessert miscalculation.

“It was the wedding cake,” he confirmed, jokingly adding how he even attempted to “fix it with the fork.”

Though the Saturday Night Live alum acknowledged the situation was “bad” and happened just “an hour before it was supposed to be presented” to Selena, Benny and their guests, the wedding coordinator and chef were able to salvage the sweet treat.

As Martin put it, “It ended up being a Hollywood wedding cake: beautiful but now it had a little bit of work done.”

But it was Selena’s reaction to the cake snafu that was most memorable for Martin.

“I kept saying we can’t let Selena know,” he said, “and then as I was leaving, Selena came by and said, ‘Hey Marty, I heard you tried to eat my cake!’”

Todd Owyoung/NBC via Getty Images

Dessert drama aside, Martin shared what it meant to be part of their special day. “It is such a great thing to go to a wedding where you just know that these people are perfect for each other,” he emphasized. “Selena is like an extra child of mine, we adore her so much. She found this guy and he’s the greatest guy.”

Selena, 33, and Benny, 37, tied the knot on Sept. 27, nine months after the music producer popped the question. 

Martin isn’t the only Only Murders star who has shared insight into the wedding. Steve, 80, also raved about the “beautiful, beautiful wedding” in November, telling Entertainment Tonight, “She married a very lucky guy, but also a very talented and funny guy.”

Francis Specker/CBS via Getty Images

For her part, Selena has been living on a cloud since becoming a wife. As the “Who Says” singer put it to Apple Music in November, “It has been a dream so far. I know it will come with ebbs and flows, but it’s the most beautiful person that I can do that with.”

For more on Gomez and Blanco’s love story, keep reading…

Kevin Winter/WireImage / Stefanie Keenan/Getty Images for Rare Impact Fund

Blossoming Romance

Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco began dating in July 2023, around Selena's birthday, Benny said on the Howard Stern Show in May 2024.

But they only began to spark romance rumors in late 2023. That December, Selena confirmed the speculation, commenting on a fan page's Instagram post, regarding Benny, "He is my absolute everything in my heart."

She continued, "Why has he been the best thing that's ever happened to me. He's still better than anyone I've ever been with."

The Rare Beauty founder also shared a photo on her Instagram Story of her leaning her head on what looked to be Benny's chest.

Instagram/@selenagomez

With This Ring...

Selena later shared this pic on her Instagram Stories, which shows her wearing a bejeweled "B" ring.

Instagram/@selenagomez

That Kiss

...including a pic of the two kissing. 

Instagram / Selena Gomez

Quality Time

Also in December 2023, Selena shared several photos of herself hanging out in New York City with Benny and their friends.i

Instagram, Selena Gomez

Appreciating Art

Two days after Christmas 2023, Selena shared new pics of the couple at what appeared to be an art exhibit.

Instagram / Selena Gomez

PDA Alert

Selena posted this pic of herself and Benny one day before New Year's Eve 2023.

Allen Berezovsky/Getty Images

Slam Dunk Date Night

The pair attended the Los Angeles Lakers' home game against the Miami Heat in January 2024.

Instagram/Selena Gomez

Can't Keep Their Hands to Themselves

The couple packed on PDA in this February 2024 snapshot.

Instagram / Selena Gomez

Happy Birthday Benny

Selena shared a tribute to her boyfriend on his 36th birthday in March 2024.

Instagram / Selena Gomez

Birthday Tribute

"Happy birthday baby!" Selena wrote on her Instagram. "Your emotional endurance, positive disposition, unbelievable talent (that blows me away), undeniable humor and loving, kind heart absolutely kill me. I love you @itsbennyblanco."

Instagram / Selena Gomez

PDA Alert

Selena included this kissing pic in her birthday tribute to Benny.

Instagram / Selena Gomez

Naughty PDA Alert

...and these couple's pics as well.

Instagram/Selena Gomez

Open Book

Selena celebrated the release of Benny's Open Wide in April 2024, captioning photos of the pair enjoying a cake shaped like his cookbook, "So proud."

Instagram / Selena Gomez

Happy Fourth of July

Selena shared this pic of the two on Independence Day 2024.

TikTok / Selena Gomez

Who Said "I Love You" First?

In July 2024, just ahead of their first dating anniversary, the two answered a viral "Who's Most Likely To" TikTok challenge, during which they were asked who was the first to say "I love you" to the other person. The answer? Selena.

Instagram

Getting Cozy

Selena and Benny cuddled up in cute photos in July 2024 following her 32nd birthday.

Instagram

Night Adventures

The actress captioned a gallery of summer photos, "Thank you for sharing your life with me today and everyday."

Instagram

Beach Babes

The musicians soaked up the sun together on lounge chairs.

Instagram

Dinner Date

Selena shared a silly pic of the two enjoying a bite.

Instagram

Summer of Love

They're just loving each other like a love song, baby.

Instagram

Incognito

The two were bundled up with masks on during one of their outings.

Instagram

Pucker Up!

In another snap, Selena wore Benny's beanie as they pursed their lips for the camera.

Instagram

Not Single Soon

The "Eastside" artist gave Selena a kiss on the cheek in a sweet summer snap in July 2024.

Instagram

Good for You

He wrapped his arms around her in another adorable Instagram pic.

Instagram / Selena Gomez

She Said Yes!

"Forever begins now," Selena wrote in December 2024, while revealing their engagement. Benny quipped in the comments, "hey wait… that’s my wife."

Michael Buckner/GG2025/Penske Media via Getty Images

Golden Couple

The couple enjoyed a date night at the 2025 Golden Globes.

David Fisher / Shutterstock

Red Carpet Debut

Benny and Selena made their first joint red carpet appearance at the 2025 Emmys.

Benny Blanco/Instagram

Tying the Knot

The pair got married in Santa Barbara, Calif., on Sept. 27, 2025, with guests including Taylor SwiftMartin Short, Steve Martin and Paul Rudd.

Selena Gomez/Instagram

Day of Thanks

The Only Murders in the Building star and music producer cozied up together for their first Thanksgiving together as a married couple, two months after tying the knot.

For the latest breaking news updates, click here to download the E! News App

Read Entire Article