8 Must-Watch Crime Dramas for Fans of His & Hers

Adapted from Alice Feeney’s novel, His & Hers has quickly proven why prestige crime dramas continue to dominate modern television. Instead of presenting crime as a puzzle with easy answers, the series leans into emotional fallout and psychological tension. Like many modern crime thriller series, it focuses on fractured relationships, unreliable perspectives, and the lasting cost of uncovering the truth.

The success of His & Hers on Netflix has been instantaneous. Now, fans are on the hunt for more post-crime dramas, psychological thrillers, and slow-burn mystery series. Fortunately, there is a vast selection of similarly compelling options across TV that will keep them watching. These shows emphasize character-driven storytelling, layered performances, and atmosphere over procedural formula.

True Detective (2014-Present)

Watch OnHBO Max

If somehow you have yet to see True Detective, now is your chance. It has a familiar tonal gravity to His & Hers, and is a series that prioritizes atmosphere, moral complexity, and damaged protagonists over conventional procedural thrills. Like the Netflix drama, it treats crime as a catalyst for examining identity, memory, and long-term trauma.

Each season of True Detective follows a new cast and storyline, most famously beginning with detectives investigating a ritualistic murder in Louisiana. Matthew McConaughey’s powerful portrayal of Detective Rust Cohle is often cited by fans as one of the most iconic TV detectives of the 2010s. The show’s slow pacing, philosophical dialogue, and emphasis on character psychology helped redefine prestige crime television.

Mare Of Easttown (2021)

Watch On HBO Max

Like His & Hers, Mare Of Easttown focuses on how a traumatic event can ripple through a close-knit community. Rather than centering on spectacle, the series emphasizes grief, memory, and unresolved emotional scars, making it ideal for viewers who value character-driven crime drama.

Set in a small Pennsylvania town, the show stars Kate Winslet as a detective investigating a local murder while navigating her own personal losses. Mare of Easttown excels at exploring how truth is shaped by grief and personal trauma, grounding its mystery in deeply human pain. Following the drama’s critical and commercial success, Kate Winslet has stated that there is a strong possibility for Mare of Easttown season 2.

The Killing (2011-2014)

Watch On Hulu

Viewers drawn in by the deliberate pacing of His & Hers will appreciate The Killing. The series stretches a single investigation across an entire season. Rather than focusing on a quick resolution, it explores the emotional fallout of the crime.

Originally a Danish series, the American version follows detectives probing the murder of a teenage girl in Seattle. Within this investigation, we also witness the victim’s family and the political ramifications surrounding the case. The show’s bleak aesthetic and refusal to offer easy answers make it a standout post-crime drama.

Broadchurch

Watch On Netfli

With Broadchurch's 92% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, the British series is essential viewing for fans of His & Hers. Both shows examine how crime fractures trust and exposes long-buried secrets, focusing less on shock value and more on emotional consequence.

Starring David Tennant and Oscar winner Olivia Colman, the series follows detectives investigating the death of a young boy. What sets Broadchurch apart is its compassionate portrayal of grief and the way suspicion corrodes relationships. Broadchurch prioritizes character integrity over procedural gimmicks, cementing its status as a landmark British crime series.

Big Little Lies (2017-Present

Watch On HBO Max

Big Little Lies is also adapted from a novel, this time by Liane Moriarty. While Big Little Lies season 2 leans more toward domestic drama, its structural similarities to His & Hers make it a compelling recommendation.

Big Little Lies centers on a group of women whose seemingly perfect lives unravel after a mysterious death. Through nonlinear narratives and shifting viewpoints, the series explores guilt, trauma, and suppressed violence. With its star-studded cast, and the show earning multiple Emmy Awards, a third season has been officially confirmed. Now is the time to catch up on the acclaimed Big Little Lies before its return.

The Madness (2024)

Watch On Netflix

For those drawn in by the psychological disorientation seen in His & Hers, The Madness offers a more overtly paranoid take on post-crime storytelling. The thriller follows Muncie Daniels (Colman Domingo), a man who becomes entangled in a murder conspiracy that challenges his perception of reality.

While more politically charged, The Madness shares the same fascination with subjective truth and media manipulation as His & Hers.

Though it earned a solid 76% on Rotten Tomatoes, The Madness largely flew under the radar upon release. Its tightly controlled pacing and escalating sense of paranoia elevate the show into a compelling modern conspiracy thriller.

Behind Her Eyes (2021)

Watch On Netflix

Another thriller many have yet to watch, but is a perfect show for His & Hers fans, is Behind Her Eyes. Like His & Hers, Behind Her Eyes encourages viewers to question what they’re seeing and why characters interpret events the way they do.

Becoming known for its unsettling tone and controversial twists, the Netflix limited series follows a single mother caught in a dangerous emotional triangle, gradually revealing darker psychological layers. While more surreal than His & Hers in its execution, Behind Her Eyes shares a commitment to psychological suspense and slow reveals.

Run Away (2026)

Watch On Netflix

Like His & Hers, Run Away frames crime as a deeply personal rupture rather than a distant event. It focuses on personal loss and buried family secrets, which will feel instantly familiar to His & Hers fans. The latest Harlan Coben Netflix novel adaptation, the British thriller follows parents Simon and Paige Greene as they search for their missing daughter.

Like many Coben adaptations, Run Away emphasizes emotional stakes and moral ambiguity over action. Its exploration of grief and denial aligns closely with character-focused crime drama, and Run Away has been a major hit on Netflix, so much so that it has surged to the top of the rankings, knocking Stranger Things off the number 1 spot.